Juliskania's Rhodoks

See here for full story)
http://www.t-k-o-s.info/forum/index.php?topic=1337.new;boardseen#new

Redworah:James was the best tactical commander we had and now we have noone else who can be trusted enough of that title that we know of really so i guess we need to pick one of our low rank militia men and expect him to lead a whole army either that or me or repel will need to risk our lives as commanders neither seems very pleasant and now we are in a bit of a stretch. Not to mention im sure Repel was aware of James's behavior from that chat anyways before he appointed him leader so now all rhodokia is likely gona need to scrap together a commander. Sad

Blue:(Once again you are mixing up OOC things with IC things, you should really work on your ability draw the line between what is OOC and IC, but ofcourse this is not an easy task. Please just try to pay attention to this.

Let me explain what i mean:

The reason why i dont trust Deathlinger with such a high position is because i think his short fuse and strange attitude will lead to complications in both OOC organisation management, IC organisation management, and the choices he will let his character make during the role play resulting in faulty commands and orders he will issue to the troops. When i say faulty commands i mean decisiosn that may be influenced by his somewhat dominant/agresive nature, basically i don't think his view is objective enough for him to come to proper judgement, i will gladly let him convince me otherwise with showing me how he improves his (so far) negative attitude, and how he role plays in game.

As for the tactics thing, whoever gets issued the new position is free to receive any OOC instruction from anyone to implement certain tactics or other abilities that the player may need to successfully role play his character to the fullest extent, if Deathlinger is good with commanding and tactics then he should simply OOCly teach it to the new militia commander so that his/her in game acts will correspond with his/her in game commanding performance.

The fact that people are right now militia ranks in game doesnt say a single thing about their IC/OOC capabilities and skills of judgement, objective view, management, administration and all the other important things, i feel like this needs no othe explanation.

There is more then enough time to find a capable new commander, don't worry about that. What i personally am worrying about tho is that once again you seem to think that the very day the sever goes up you will need a commander to lead you in battle, which is absolutely the opposite what is goign to happen. The emphasis is on role play, not battle.)Blue)

Edit:
Quote from: Redworah
So if being calm and level headed and way open minded and gentle and kind and courteous was all that mattered in rping a commander we may as well make Lady Venus Lancaster leader. But we need someone who knows how to order and command and do so with decent authority to lead which rhodokia does not have huge abundances of.

Blue:Once again you're mixing up OOC and IC. It doesnt matter what kind of character will be fulfilling the role, wether he/she is a bad or good, angry or happy person, whatever (as long as it fits within the scenario ofcourse). What does matter is the abilities of the person playing the character to both properly role play all the complex aspects of such a rank aswell as those same OOC aspects.

Blue:May i remind you that you are stating a thought you have as a fact right now:

Quote from: Redworah
we need someone who knows how to order and command and do so with decent authority to lead which rhodokia does not have huge abundances of

Blue:I'm not very sure of the fact that you have a full view on all abilities of all those involved, so please refrain from such statements. The admin team will take a good look at it and then come to a decision.