You as an individual are fine separating an individual from what they create and solely enjoying their content for what it's worth.
While others wouldn't be fine with that. I personally can get behind that to some extend but I'd definitely at least draw the line for individuals like Andrew Tate.
So if you're fine with that I can definitely see how if people aren't fine with you liking certain content, based on the individual that created it, seems really weird and wrong.