I would recommend The Inn-Sanity without a shadow of doubt!

1. Characters 10000/10
Robin, Watcher, White Lady and annoying Priest have done their best to impress me and I think all players!
They're extra ordinary and non-trivial like the most horror games have.

2. Plot
Firstly I though that It's just somebody's unlogical nightmare but It turn out to be a good a apocalypse. The story keeps developing and the plot twist abruptly shocks you. Characters keeps developing with the story. They feel very very real.

3. CHOICE MATTERS
One of the rare games where you have to make a right decision and your answers make an impact on the story and destinies of characters.

An only thing I would recommend to developers to make a kind of choice to save Watcher. It would be great If a player had an opportunity to prevent Watcher's death/